Skip to content

September 14th – September 20th, 2024

September 14th – September 20th 2024

Glasgow Will Host the Games; Lomond Banks Deal is Off; but first …..

The Unknown Clearances

            Have you ever noticed the ruined cottages dotted round the country?  Not completely ruined.  The roof is totally off but the walls appear fairly sturdy.  Perhaps you thought the elements were to blame?  Maybe not entirely.  Often only the roof is gone, which ensured the house was effectively destroyed and unusable and served to exempt the owners from business rates.

            Professor Douglas MacMillan and Euan Stevenson have been documenting a deliberate ‘programme of ruination’ of homes in Scotland’s state forestry*.  These were ‘perfectly good homes’ with some standing near houses which are still family homes in good condition.  The ruins are not the by-product of agricultural clearances but were 19th century stone-built farm buildings, more often found in Galloway and in the north-east.

           The authors allege the UK Forestry Commission pursued an active programme of ruination and abandonment or deliberate destruction of hundreds of homes on land they acquired for purposes of afforestation, which was required due to severe timber shortages following World War I.  Scotland’s forests remained under UK government control until 2003. 

           One of the most notable examples is Aros House on Mull, built in 1825, acquired in 1959 by the Forestry Commission, and demolished using explosives during a training exercise by the British Army in 1962.  The authors are calling on Forestry and Land Scotland (FLS) to do a full inventory of ruined properties on FLS-owned land and formulate a plan to restore or reuse them for community benefit.

*Ruination On The National Forest Estate 1920-2019, MacMillan and Stevenson.

Lomond Banks Deal is Off!

            …… for now.  Following almost 175,000 objections, Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority (LLTNP) unanimously rejected a re-submitted plan for a resort including a monorail, water park, lodges and a hotel.  The Woodlands Trust objection that ancient woodland would be destroyed seems to have won the day, given that the park authority’s first aim is to conserve and enhance the area’s natural heritage. Only 69 people wrote supporting the plans.  But it is likely that the developers will now appeal to the Scottish government.

Scotland is Dead if Grangemouth Shuts

            The SNP government response to closure was very muted.  Project Willow, the £1.5 million study looking at long-term options for the site, may not create jobs for another 5 to 10 years.  And what do we make of comparably-sized Denmark having 300,000 manufacturing jobs and Ireland 275,000 while Scotland is down to 173,000?  The European Union as a whole had over 32 million manufacturing jobs in 2022.

What is ‘Financially Unviable’

            in the context of lost jobs and economic devastation?  Grangemouth’s closure leaves Scotland without an oil refinery, while Stanlow near Liverpool, one of England’s five refineries, is gearing up by investing in new terminals and storage facilities to fill the gap left by Grangemouth.  Despite a refining capacity of 150,000 barrels a day (14% of the total UK refining capacity), supplying up to 80% of refined fuel to Scotland and the north of England, and turning a profit for Petroineos Manufacturing Scotland Limited of £107.4 million pre-tax last year, Grangemouth is expendable.   

            How much money is lost to the economy when nearly 4000 supply chain and other jobs go?  How much is lost when a community is hollowed out? And what message does it send that the only one of the top 25 oil producers is allowing its only oil refinery to shut?

Only £20 million looks like ‘new’ money

            Although the area may get more future ‘support’ from the National Wealth Fund, the £100 million currently pledged to help comprises £20 million from the UK and Scottish governments, with the remaining £80 million coming from the Falkirk and Grangemouth Growth Deal.  But the Growth Deal has been around since December 2021, so it may be that only £20 million is ‘new’ money. Conversely, the UK government recently agreed a £600-million loan guarantee to Ineos’ plans for a petrochemical plant in Belgium.

Saving Grangemouth

           Stacey Oil in Aberdeen is brokering a potential buyout by a significant unnamed North American company which is considering ‘vertically integrating’ Grangemouth refinery into its set-up (meaning the acquisition of whole components of a manufacturing process into your overall entity to obtain greater efficiency and control over processes longer-term).

Rest and Be Thankful

            Design and assessment work has eaten up £16 million in four years trying to solve the problem of landslips on the A83 in Argyll and Bute.  Last year it was agreed to build a ‘shelter’ over the road to protect it from falling debris, with continued use of the Old Miliary Road meantime.

            Transport Secretary Fiona Hyslop expects draft orders for comment to be published by the end of 2024, with improvements ongoing to the Old Military Road through Glen Croe.  The latest award in July was £5.5 million for ground investigations.

Cash for Access?

           The Scottish Greens are facing questions over so-called ‘cash for access’ lunches with government ministers and MSPs.  For £700 a head, anyone could pay to meet senior Green politicians at their recent conference at the time when Patrick Harvie and Lorna Slater were government ministers.  Previous conferences had offered only the chance to network with members, not to meet MSPs or ministers.

           The Scottish Greens said it is all above board and they have always declared relevant meetings and discussions as required under the Lobbying (Scotland) Act 2016.

Fort William At Crisis Point

            Lochaber Chamber of Commerce is calling for major improvements to alleviate traffic congestion around Fort William, mwhich they claim is hampering economic growth.  The need to upgrade the A82 to reduce traffic congestion is cited as a major impediment to firms like MOWI, Ferguson Transport & Shipping and BSW Timber, which is looking to expand its operations.  The SSE’s Coire Glas Pumped Hydro Storage Scheme is also impacted.

            The Scottish government said it is working with local authorities to finalise improvements to the transport infrastructure in the area.

Is Small Beautiful

            for local democracy?  Building a Local Scotland (BLS) recently launched its ‘Local Democracy Declaration’ calling for more local councils to allow greater citizen participation, as well as citizens’ assemblies.  They cite Highland Council, which serves over 235,000 people in an area the size of Belgium, where the average council covers only 20,000 people, and Europe in general with councils covering only 10,000 residents.  The average Scottish council covers 170,000 people, meaning people feel distanced from decision-making and disengaged, with an average of 1 councillor per 4,100 residents.  Even in England they have one councillor per 2814 people. 

Small Councils’ Disproportionate Effect

            Oslo resident Mike Fergus, writing in the National, while acknowledging the importance of local democracy, says this gives small authorities disproportionate power.  Because all Norwegian local authorities have extensive planning powers, the wider regional impact of decisions is ignored.  Holiday resort Rauland, 125 miles from Oslo, part of Vinje Municipality (population 3832) has allowed 4000 mountain cabins to be built, greatly impacting the nearby environment with road-building and traffic congestion over which they have no say.  Likewise Ikea has two large outlets in Oslo City, serving 600,000 people.  A small local authority just outside Oslo, serving 18,000 people, is considering a new Ikea store which would bring 300 new jobs but would impact the Oslo outlets.

          Although smaller councils bring greater democracy, their decisions can hugely impact surrounding areas who have no say in the decision.  Is that democratic?

Should the Old Firm Get Special Treatment?

            In recent months Hibs, Hearts, St Mirren and now St Johnstone made what appears at first a perverse decision to cut the away ticket allocation when Rangers or Celtic visit.  The clubs want to be less reliant on a few Old Firm games a year.  There is no set allocation for away tickets in the SPFL rules, except that the allocation is ‘reasonable’.

            The clubs argue that their grounds belong to the home fans and they want to foster a sense of ‘belonging’ for them rather than make a quick profit from away fans.  St Mirren’s recent experiment worked out for them by increasing ticket receipts from £1.2 million to £1.6 million over the year.  Their Family Stand is no longer taken over by away fans, but used to promote the home fan base.

            When St Johnstone opted last year to hand over all but the main stand to Rangers fans for a cup tie, only 400 home fans turned up, with the rest staying away in protest at being made to feel like the away fans in their own ground.  They are now hoping to replicate St Mirren’s success in attracting and keeping their own fans.

Glasgow WILL host the 2026 Commonwealth Games

            Although not without controversy, particularly the Commonwealth’s roots in Empire, Glasgow will host a slimmed-down programme in 2026.  Health Secretary Neil Gray secured more funding from Commonwealth Games Australia, so no public money will be needed, nor will any Scottish government financial guarantees.  The Commonwealth Games Federation (CGF) will cover most of the funding via £100 million compensation paid by the Australian State of Victoria, who unexpectedly backed out of staging the Games. The CGF is also providing a further £20 million including £5 million for Glasgow to use for ‘capital upgrades and a cultural programme’.

            The UK is providing a ‘ringfenced contingency fund’ up to £2.3 million for strictly emergency use, in addition to a £27 million contingency fund.  The Games are expected to cost £114 million, with £14 million from private finance. But does anyone know why it was the Health Secretary fronting up this announcement?

Finally:

Is Scottish Independence like the Death Penalty?

            Former head strategist of Better Together and now Scottish Labour MP Blair McDougall seems to think so in that people have very strong emotive views on the death penalty which don’t influence how we vote at elections, and that belief in independence, being emotive and illogical, should also be kept at bay at election time.  

            Lib Dem Alex Cole-Hamilton may have gone one better by bringing God into a Holyrood debate this week only to say we should leave Him out when we vote.

            Not sure that comparing independence to the death penalty is the unionist vote-winner McDougall thinks.  But it’s good to have Labour and the LibDems there to stop us being too emotive.  

Better Together …..

Cookie Consent with Real Cookie Banner