Skip to content

Police Still have a ‘Woman Problem’

UK Police Still Have a ‘Woman Problem’

           International Women’s Day is a time not only to celebrate women, but to ask what has changed since last year.  The answer, sadly, is not very much.

          It is five years since the murder of Sarah Everard in Kent, but the horror of the circumstances is not dimmed.  In the middle of a pleasant, mild evening, Sarah disappeared while walking home along crowded streets in London, a short journey of 50 minutes where she would have felt no fear with so many people around.  She would not be found for a week almost 100 miles away, not just dead but her body desecrated in death.

          But what unfolded became a horror story of missed opportunities to unmask a predator who wore a police uniform; and serious questions about the lack of serious vetting for police officers, those we are led to believe are one of the class of public servants we can automatically trust because they wear the uniform, sworn to serve and protect the public and uphold the strictest standards.

          For her killer was a serving Metropolitan Police officer, Wayne Couzens.  That was bad enough, but there had been numerous opportunities to root out this evil man from the force.  It transpired he was a member of a ‘What’s App’ group which denigrated women and where he was nicknamed ‘The Rapist’ by other officers including David Carrick, who was eventually found guilty of multiple rapes and jailed for over 30 years. 

          Couzens’ vetting for various police forces failed to root him out, starting with Thames Valley Police, who should have failed him on financial vetting.  There were escalating and sexual offences over the years, including indecent exposure.  Just before Sarah’s abduction, he twice exposed himself to staff at McDonald’s in Swanley, Kent, on 14th and 27th February 2021.  Classed as ‘low risk’ by police, an officer was only dispatched to formally note the incidents on the day of the abduction. Incredibly, no action was taken against him despite Couzens’ vehicle registration being clearly visible on cctv and his credit card details known.

          After killing Sarah, Couzens burned her body and dumped her in woodland, allowing his children to play where he had left her.  Couzens’ deviousness and violence had escalated for many years, including the use of violent pornography.

          Police compounded their ‘crimes’ against Sarah by heavy-handed policing of a vigil in her memory, including wrestling a woman to the ground and linking arms against the protesters as if they were a violent, baying mob.

          The Angiolini Report into how Couzens was able to use his job as a shield for violent sexual crimes demanded much better vetting and recruitment procedures, as well as better ongoing monitoring of every police officer throughout their career.  This included a requirement to automatically check the Barred and Advisory Lists as part of the vetting process to ensure officers cannot just be sacked from one force and join another.  But suspicions remain that many ‘bad apples’ remain in place and that vetting is not fit for purpose.

Is Scotland any better?

          Doubtful.  Freedom of Information Requests have revealed that the number one reason for police suspensions in Scotland over the last 10 years was sexual misconduct, with 111 allegations against police officers resulting in suspension from duty, over a third of all suspensions. 

          The numbers were lower between 2015 and 2020, with the highest annual number of suspensions for sexual misconduct in a single year over that period being 13, followed by 7 suspensions in 2021, but the figures then jumped to 23 in 2022 before falling again to 16 in 2025.

          There is currently no clear process to require people to self-report significant changes in personal circumstances to their police employers after initial vetting has been completed.  Vetting in legacy forces prior to the establishment of Police Scotland was not standardised and no new vetting of staff happened on the creation of the unified force.  Despite Police Scotland indicating it will randomly review recruitment vetting for 3% to 5% of its staff, it is unclear if this has happened. 

          A higher level called ‘management vetting’ is done every 7 years on those working with vulnerable people or who have access to sensitive information, but the list of posts it applies to appears arbitrary and has not been revisited since 2013.

          And the force’s attempt to improve vetting procedures under the Police (Ethics, Conduct and Scrutiny) (Scotland) Act 2025 (PECSS) have currently run aground after police tried to extend the same rules to civilian staff as to police officers, despite civilians and staff having a differing legal standing, particularly in relation to the Duty of Candour.

           So significant gaps in protection remain, and it is doubtful whether women in Scotland should feel any more confident that police have rooted out their ‘woman problem’ yet, particularly as Police Scotland are only just starting to address the general problem of misogyny, a problem exacerbated by their unwillingness or inability hitherto to even identify what a woman is.     

Julia Pannell

08/03/2026

Cookie Consent with Real Cookie Banner